An Open Letter to NBC

By Meghanpedia 21 Comments

To whom it may concern:
For the past three years the Duchess of Sussex has endured much racist, xenophobic, misogynist, and dehumanizing attacks from the reporters of the British media. This brings into focus a particular Royal Correspondent and Journalist who currently serves as a Royal Expert for your network, Ms. Camilla Tominey.

A careful examination of her reporting concerning the Duchess of Sussex reveals an unquestionable amount of bias. She consistently criticizes the Duchess for doing the exact same things other members of the Royal Family have done for years, such as guest editing a magazine, wearing a one-shoulder dress, etc. Either the other royals are praised or the act is ignored. The Duchess has been labelled as “uppity”, which has a long history of a negative view of people of color.

Ms. Tominey reports on information which she knows to be false and when confronted about her false and biased reporting, she either doubles down on the falsehood or denies that she ever wrote it. There is an abundance of proof, also known in the social media environment as receipts, to support these claims.

Exhibit A

November 2018 The Telegraph. “Meghan Mosque” by Camilla Tominey. This article basically linked the Mosque in which the Hubb community kitchen operates to terrorism. If you will recall, the community kitchen is made up of women who survived the horrific Grenfell Tower fire in London. It was the Duchess’s first solo project which she initiated before becoming a member of the Royal Family. In September of 2018, she and the women presented a cookbook entitled, Together, which quickly became a bestseller.

I believe Mrs Tominey purposely titled her article “Meghan Mosque“ knowing full well there is a particular section of society that simply dislike people of a certain religious persuasion and she did so without bothering to consider the consequences of her reporting and the individual lives she was putting in danger. She tied the Duchess to violent people who committed horrendous acts years before she ever set foot in the U.K., at the same time, Prince Harry and Duchess Meghan were targeted by right-wing extremists. Ms. Tominey has stated that the Duchess needs to work with grassroots people. The women of the Hubb Community Kitchen are grassroots people, so perhaps Ms. Tominey should clearly define who represents grassroots in her world.

Exhibit B

Prior to the release of the September 2019 issue of British Vogue, members of the British Press began writing negative opinion pieces. They were labelling her Meghan Markle, the Actress or the self centered one because they were so sure the edition would be all about her and her comfortable life as a Duchess. She destroyed their narratives because much to their dismay, Duchess Meghan did not appear on the cover, instead she presented 15 remarkable women as “Forces for Change.”

In the article she wrote for The Telegraph Ms. Tominey states, “I wonder whether Meghan was conscious of the bias she showed in choosing 15 “Forces for Change” for the British Vogue cover, all of whom were women of which five were white?” Her criticism, in my opinion, is harsh and lacks comprehension of the impact of this project. First and foremost she accused the Duchess of overlooking white women when indeed white women represent 33% of the faces on the cover. In other words for Ms. Tominey, the cover was not “white enough.” How dare the Duchess make the edition diverse and inclusive! Just a little research would have revealed that white women have dominated the cover of British Vogue for many years. She also used this as an opportunity to become the unsolicited voice of older white men, by stating, “If I was pale, male and stale, I’d be feeling pretty discriminated against right now.” That, in and of itself, echoes a sort of white superiority complex. People swiftly spoke out against the article and lambasted The Telegraph, calling both Tominey’s argument and the promotion of it racist.

Even though Ms. Tominey wants to appear as being concerned about “standing up for the rights of an oppressed minority or gender”, I read her articles as that of a woman unhappy with a woman of color that uses her platform to raise and amplify the voices of other women who are truly members of the oppressed minority and/or gender.

Women supporting other women should not be based on race, creed, color, religion or sexual orientation and I would think a trained well-informed journalist would support this. Therefore, based on the information provided, I employ you to reconsider providing Ms. Tominey with a platform to appear on an American network to spread her lies and biased agenda on an American citizen, HRH The Duchess of Sussex.

Respectfully submitted,

Kerriann C.

More on Camilla Tominey

Her claim to fame is that she broke the story of Prince Harry dating then actress Meghan Markle while working as the royal correspondent for the Daily Express. Since then she has moved on to the Telegraph with a Twitter bio that reads “Award-winning journalist and broadcaster. Associate Editor covering politics and royals”.

She is one who will fiercely defend the British press as being free and fair. She often argues that there is no bias in any way shape or form, as far as the reporting on the Duchess of Sussex is concerned. Very frequently she attempts to distance the mainstream media from online media claiming that online media publishes with impunity since the mainstream media is regulated by IPSO (International Press Standards Organisation).

Now I don’t want to go into the details of IPSO, which you can read here, but it is worth noting that each time Camilla is challenged on the standard of reporting she uses the illusion of regulation by IPSO which has been found to be a problematic organisation.

But perhaps one of the areas where Camilla failed herself and journalism in general was in the articles that she published where she linked the Duchess of Sussex’s first project – Together Community Cookbook to terrorism.

With no regard for the impact such an article would have on the victims of the Grenfell Tower who had been supported by this initiative and are simply trying to get by, Camilla went into full blown hyperbole with this story with only one intent which was to undermine the project and stir up hate towards the Duchess of Sussex among her predominantly right-wing readers. There is no justifiable reason why Camilla would make this kind of association at a time when Islamophobia runs high following the Brexit campaign which has been dogged with distasteful narratives against immigrants and Muslims. The author of the so-called report she refenced, a member of a white supremacy group, later thanked her on twitter for taking their story.

If this hate-driven narrative was not enough to demonstrate bias and ill intentions, the Vogue September issue Forces for change, showed the lengths to which Camilla was willing to go to undermine the Duchess of Sussex’s work. Earlier in the week of its release, she appeared on an Australian TV show in which she argued that by choosing to work with an elitist magazine, Meghan was turning her back on the ordinary British public and she should have instead worked with grassroots organisations. This was an indication that at the time of giving her critique, Camilla had not read the magazine because she would have noted a feature on Luminary Bakery – a grassroot organisation providing skills and other social services to victims of gender violence. Note the irony in this characterization from a woman who associated the Duchess of Sussex’s first project with a grassroots organisation with terrorism. She went ahead to call it misguided and patronising, demonstrated her lack of understanding of unconscious bias when she deliberately misrepresented the Duke of Sussex’s comments on this topic and finally complained that the cover was not white enough with only 5 out of the 15 women featured being white.

Like Piers Morgan, a full commentary on Camilla Tominey requires an article of its own but thankfully you can find more details at this link. For all her writing or commentary Camilla has never written or reported on the Duchess of Sussex’s successful initiative. At the very least she could acknowledge that saying that most British people could not afford a £2 magazine was misplaced (to put it mildly) because the issue sold out within 2 weeks.

When people question where the online hate for Meghan comes from, they only have to look to triggers such as this. It is worth noting that Camilla has never offered a retraction and there has been no public acknowledgement of IPSO looking into this hate-ridden kind of reporting so it is safe to assume that both Camilla and IPSO stand by and uphold this quality and standard of work.

Spread some Duchess of Sussex facts

Last updated on October 27th, 2019

21 comments on “An Open Letter to NBC

  1. Yaa Boama

    Thank you Meghanpedia for your tireless work in highlighting the maltreatment of Duchess Meghan who has not put a foot wrong and thank you for taking things further by writing to the television network. Like the Duchess said, if you see something which is not right, you must do something about it and thank you for doing something about it. #WeLoveYouMeghan #WeStandWithTheSussexes #IStandWithTheSussexes.

    I look forward to your articles. You have my 100% support.

    Reply
  2. Trinette L Mitchell

    I just want to know this woman has been fired! We don’t need her kind of reporting here in the States. Our country is going through enough with a clown in the White House and his band of goon buffoons, we don’t need this trash invading our country with her crap!

    Reply
  3. vonzola adams

    SO, WHAT HAS NBC DONE REGARDING YOUR OPEN LETTER? SOULD WE START A CAMPAIGN TO THE SPONORS? HOW CAN I FIND OUT WHAT HAS BEEN DONE ABOUT THE ROYAL REPORTERS (SPECIFICALLY TOMINEY) AND REPORTING OF LIES. CAN NBC BE CHARGED WITH AIDING AND ABETTING STORIES THAT KNOWN TO BE FALSE? PLEASE EMAIL ME ALL UPDATES.

    Reply
  4. arnold sanders

    Wondering out loud. Thou I agree with everything you have written. Does these type of letters ever reach the intended eyes? This is done online. Did you send it to them directly? Maybe put it on a mainstream online site? Just wondering.

    Reply
  5. Ruth D'Franco

    Indeed! I knew that she was going to shake things up to a different new dimension when I saw her walking down the aisle alone and saw her confidence and determination then. I am honestly deeply disturbed by the unfair treatment she has been exposed to by some reporters in the UK. I never knew Ms Markle and never followed the royals, I am from El Salvador, C.A. except now for Duchess Meghan. She is an example to the world and deserves better than this. I am so proud of this modern, inclusive, amazing and caring, Duchess Meghan. The world is watching, leave her alone and treat her with the respect and dignity she deserves.

    Reply
  6. Dinah

    Thank you for this open letter.
    But again, this is not the first letter NBC and other USA networks have received about this and other British correspondents/commentator, constantly reporting untrued and negative on Meghan, for almost three years now. So if you keep ignoring our complains, we need to upscale addressing your advertisers as well.

    We simple ask you,
    1. Check her/ their ”work”.
    Sometime they will mislead the US networks by ‘softening their tone a bit – but still come up with a smear or denigrating comment – while reporting on your programs. But do check their UK contributions, and you will be horrified. This woman, an almost all other UK reporters, commenting on US TV shows/networks, have the same bias and character defaming approach towards HRH Duchess Meghan.
    2. Reconsider you contract with/the reporting of these vile reporter(s), who do not adhere to the basic rules nor the standards of journalism.

    Reply
  7. Gladys

    Good work kerrianne, thank you so much, that Camilla Tominy woman must be getting a pay check from Kessington palace for why would she be so vile hasteful towords a woman who has excelled in everthing she has put her hands on!? yes Camilla is an envious woman whose jealousy has made her so hateful it has even deformed her face, in conclusion Camilla Torminy is a racist, envious & jealosy woman which renders her unfit to report on a person like the Duchess of Sussex.

    Reply
  8. Maureen Thompson

    Camila Tominey is just another strident and unrepentant racist who represents the Vile Brit media. While I am inclined to assign these underachievers and rogue reporters to the dustbin of oblivion, I guess there is merit in calling them out and unmasking their bullying, racist attacks and unrelenting harassment of the dynamic, hardworking Duchess of Sussex. It seems that Karma though is overtaking the rags tabloids as the “News of the World” due to a plethora of litigation has met her demise and now her sister the “Sun” is about to set permanently under a hail of criticisms and Law suits from the likes of the Duke and Duchess of Sussex and other prominent celebrities and politicians. So it’s pushback time and the rags tabloids (and even social media) are becoming insolvent as they are called to book for their transgressions.!!
    So thank you again Meghanpedia for your well researched balanced reporting and your sustained campaign against the abuse of our beloved Duchess of Sussex.#DUCHESS OF SUSSEX#DUCHESS OF SUCCESS!

    Reply
  9. Linda

    Wonderful letter! I do not read anything written by Ms Tominey! Meghan is a hardworking caring person who has been attacked without grounds. Why does she not have to back check her work…….

    Reply
    1. Christine Noke

      Exactly, all they have to do is google the guest and see what type of headlines and opinions they have. Why would networks bring in a known racist, xenophobic with 0 ethics to speak objectively? The only truly objective royal reporter I have encountered is Omid Scobie, Keirs was also balanced but the rest, just making money off the Sussex family. I refuse to watch interviews that have the likes of Camila and Jobson, they make my skin crawl.

      Reply
  10. Lola

    No other words but thank you for taking the time to do what we all in our minds would like to do but never get around to it.

    Reply
  11. Marjorie Ireland

    I have been watching this RACIST woman for years but not any more. All the US Networks who have these so called “Royal Reporters” appearing on their networks should drop these Racists immediately. If they dont, we need to call upon advertisers to boycott them and cancel all subscription to NBC.

    Reply
  12. Earlene B Torres

    Bravo Kerriann for calling out the “so called royal expert” on her true colors. How she could even sleep at night or look in the mirror and call herself a journalist is a low blow to the profession in itself. I hope NBC realizes the world is watching and will cut their ties with this fraud or they will lose their viewership with me and thousands of others who will do the same once they catch wind of this story. Thank you for featuring this!

    Reply
  13. Linda

    Thank you for writing this piece, it sheds light to the Dutchess of Sussex. Her work and her humble and human feelings just shows how much she used her title to help out the less unfortunate. The Dutchess is very kind and is with people of all walks. She shows how much she care and she’s not afraid to get her hands dirty to help out others. The media portrays her as unworthy of the Royals but in my opinion she and Prince Harry are so in tune with the plight of people. I don’t live in the UK I’m from NYS never met her but I see how’s she’s doing good but she gets attacked with the most racists people and they should be ashamed. Like Princess Diana getting hounded all the time I believe Meghan is going through the same treatments. Princess Diana’s was ver loved by the Americans for her compassion and humility that she was. Meghan is doing the same. So for reporters to say otherwise is just not only wrong but it’s disgusting and shameful closed minded people are in the UK.

    Sincerely,
    A big supporter of the Duke and Dutchess of Sussex

    Reply
  14. Helen Barberton

    Great letter, and absolutely SPOT ON on every level. I cancelled my Daily Telegraph Premium subscription because I was tired of Camilla Tominey’s snarky opinion pieces about Meghan.

    Reply

Leave a Comment:

We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.